Tarrant County sued over new commissioners court map; lawsuit claims racial discrimination
Tarrant County sued over new commissioners court map
A federal lawsuit has been filed against Tarrant County and Judge Tim O'Hare claiming the county's new Commissioners Court map intentionally discriminates based on race.
TARRANT COUNTY, Texas - A federal lawsuit has been filed against Tarrant County and Judge Tim O'Hare claiming the county's new commissioners court map intentionally discriminates based on race.
The lawsuit comes just one day after the Republican-led Commissioners Court approved the new map in a 3-2 vote.
The suit claims the new map violates the Voting Rights Act and the U.S. Constitution.
Tarrant County commissioners pass redistricting map
The Republican-led Tarrant County Commissioners Court approved a redistricting map that seeks to expand Republican seats on the court.
Tarrant County Redistricting
Tarrant County judge speaks on goal of redistricting
County Judge Tim O?Hare isn?t trying to hide his motive for redistricting: To further increase conservative leadership in Tarrant County by decreasing the number of Democrats in the commissioners court.
The backstory:
Currently, Tarrant County Commissioners Court consists of Republican County Judge Tim O'Hare, two Republican Commissioners and two Democratic commissioners.
Critics of redistricting say the new map increases the chances that at least one of the two Democratic-leaning precincts will flip during the next election.
O'Hare told FOX 4 the redistricting effort fulfills a campaign promise to increase the court's Republican majority.
"For us not to do that, when we are the controlling party, the majority party, would be foolish on our part, because we know if we lost, they would do the exact same thing," said O’Hare. "Tarrant County is alive and well in terms of being a red county and we intend to keep it that way."
Tarrant County Sued
Professor on redistricting map for Tarrant County
SMU professor spoke to FOX 4 and uses mathematics and technology to analyze the redistricting models. She says she was drawn to Tarrant County?s current process
Dig deeper:
The lawsuit says that on April 2, 2025, Tarrant County entered into a contract with the Virginia-based Public Interest Legal Foundation to redraw the districts.
According to the suit, the new map packs the bulk of the county's minority voters into one precinct while splitting the others among the three other precincts.
"While Map 7 disenfranchises just 5% of Tarrant County’s Anglo adults, it disenfranchises 19% of the County’s Black adults and 12% of its Latino adults. Black adults are thus four times more likely than Anglo adults to be disenfranchised under Map 7 and Latino adults are over twice as likely to be disenfranchised than Anglo adults," reads the suit.
Five Tarrant County voters who are now in new districts were named as plaintiffs in the lawsuit.
The suit claims the Black and Latino voters are disenfranchised because they are now unable to vote for County Commissioner in the Nov. 2026 election. Under the previous map, they would have been able to cast their ballot.
Typically, redistricting is done every 10 years after the census.
The Tarrant County Commissioners Court voted not to change it after the 2020 census.
The suit argues that there was no population imbalance or other reason to require the map change.
"Specifically, the plan was drafted and passed in a process designed to be discriminatory, at least in part, to minimize the political power of Black voters and Latino voters by limiting their ability to influence commissioner court elections to a single district out of four when minorities are the majority of residents in the County and just shy of half of eligible voters in Tarrant County," reads the suit.
The suit calls to permanently stop Tarrant County from adopting Map 7 and asks for any future maps to go under review in federal court.
What they're saying:
FOX 4 reached out to Chad Ruback, an attorney who is not involved in the case, to get some outside perspective on the situation. While Ruback confirmed that it's legal to redraw district lines for partisan purposes, he also says it will be an uphill battle for the county officials.
"On the other hand, it is not appropriate, it is not legal to redistrict for the purpose of diminishing the rights of certain classes of people like minorities," Ruback said.
According to the attorney, the county will have to prove that increasing Republican representation is not the sole purpose behind redistricting.
"I believe they could prevail if they showed that Judge O'Hare and his Republican colleagues on the commissioners court were motivated to specifically hurt minority votes," he said.
The lawsuit attempts to do just that, citing examples of previous statements made by O'Hare, and his actions in previous government positions. However, Ruback says this may not be enough evidence.
"If they have some statement made to a news reporter several years ago that sort of kind of might have suggested there might be redistricting, and it might hurt minority votes, that’s probably not going to be enough to carry their burden," said Ruback.
The other side:
O'Hare's office sent a statement to FOX 4 in response to the suit. It says, in part:
"The refusal of Democrats to accept settled law will waste Tarrant County taxpayer dollars. The commissioners court voted by a 3-2 majority for more Republican representation, which is perfectly legal under all applicable laws of the United States and the state of Texas."
What's next:
According to Ruback, if more lawsuits are filed on the same issue, they'll likely be consolidated to a single case.
More evidence may be presented in the current suit, but Ruback says it remains unclear. He said it could be months before a resolution is made in the case.
The Source: Information in this article comes from a lawsuit filed in United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas Fort Worth Division and past FOX 4 coverage.