Tarrant County Commissioners adopt controversial redistricting map

FORT WORTH, Texas - The Republican-led Tarrant County Commissioners Court approved a redistricting map that seeks to expand Republican seats on the court.

What's New:

More than 250 people signed up to speak at Tuesday’s Commissioners Court meeting, both for and against the effort to redistrict Tarrant County.

Commissioners ultimately voted 3-2 to approve Map 7.

Map 7 was considered to be the most conservative option. One thing that stands out about it is that it moves the Arlington sports stadiums and hotels into the Republican-controlled Precinct 3. 

Tinderholt for Tarrant County Commissioner

Within minutes of the vote being announced, State Rep. Tony Tinderholt, a Republican from Arlington, announced he is running for Simmons’ Precinct 2 seat.

"I’m ready to come home. As a proud Christian, 21-year combat veteran, and dedicated public servant in the Texas House of Representatives, I’m honored to announce my candidacy for Tarrant County Commissioner Precinct 2," he said in a news release.

That election is not until November 2026.

Precinct 2

Democratic Commissioner Alisa Simmons of Precinct 2 will see the most significant changes to her precinct's boundary, including moving AT&T Stadium, Globe Life Field, and Texas Live to Precinct 3.

She questioned why the consultants hired to redraw the maps were not made available for questioning and pointed out that Map 7 was not even an option presented during the four public meetings held in various communities.

What they're saying:

Commissioner Simmons told FOX 4's Amelia Jones that she plans to run for re-election despite the changes to her precinct and a newly declared republican opponent, state representative Tony Tinderholt.  

"This is racist, racial gerrymandering, it’s intentional discrimination," said Simmons. "I am going to seek reelection with a tough map, and I’ll be blockwalking from Arlington to White Settlement. Which doesn’t make any sense, but I will seek reelection."

County Judge Tim O’Hare told us he believes if Democrats had the majority, they would have made a similar move.

"So for us, not to do that, when we are the controlling party, the majority party, would be foolish on our part, because we know if we lost, they would do the exact same thing," said O’Hare.

He believes Tarrant County will see four republicans on the five-member commissioners court one day.  

"I think we’re trending in the right direction, no pun intended, and so Tarrant County is alive and well in terms of being a red county and we intend to keep it that way," said O’Hare.

Big picture view:

Typically, redistricting is done every 10 years after the census. 

The Tarrant County Commissioners Court voted not to change it after the 2020 census. 

Some people who spoke today believe the vote on redistricting violates the federal voter rights act. When Judge O’Hare was asked about the act, he cited a Supreme Court ruling that allows district boundaries to be redrawn for partisan purposes. 

He said the motion passed today was 100 percent legal.

The backstory:

Judge Tim O’Hare said the redistricting effort fulfills a campaign promise. His mission was to increase the court’s Republican majority.

Currently, the court has two Republican commissioners in addition to O’Hare and two Democratic commissioners.

The proposed precinct maps increases the chances that at least one of the two Democratic-leaning precincts will flip during the next election.

Redistricting usually occurs after the U.S. Census data is released to ensure precinct lines are balanced according to population. But the commissioners in 2021 voted not to make any changes to the maps.

Opponents have called this late redistricting effort racially discriminatory and argued it dilutes the voices of minority communities.